NJ
DWI FAQs
Note:
These FAQs (and other parts of my site) have been copied and mimicked by
other lawyer websites over the years. I have had to take legal action
against these lawyers for the unlawful action. While imitation is said
to be the best form of flattery, regrettably, these sites do a
tremendous disservice to clients who might be bamboozled into believing
that the work is authentic. Below are the genuine (and recently updated)
New Jersey DWI Frequently Asked Questions:
1. How can I be
convicted of DWI in New Jersey?
N.J.S. 39:4-50 (the NJ DWI Statute) makes it unlawful to "operate a
motor vehicle while under the influence of intoxicating liquor ... or
... with a blood alcohol concentration of .08% or more by weight of
[blood] alcohol."
The
New Jersey DWI Statute creates in effect two distinct and separate
offenses; (A) operating a motor vehicle while "under the influence of
intoxicating liquor", and (B) operating a motor vehicle with a "blood
alcohol concentration of .08% or more."
Under the influence has been defined generally as a Defendant who has
consumed alcohol "to the extent that his physical or mental faculties
are deleteriously affected." State v. Emery, 27 N.J. 348, 355
(1958). It has also been defined as a "substantial deterioration or
diminution of the mental faculties or physical capabilities of a
person." see State v. Tamburro, 68 N.J. 414, 421 (1975).
Under the second prong of the Statute, a Defendant who operates a motor
vehicle with a blood alcohol concentration of .08% or more is guilty no
matter how the alcohol affected him. This (offense) is referred to as a
"per se" offense ("Per Se" is Latin for "by itself").
2. What are the
penalties if I am convicted?
The penalties, which are set forth in N.J.S.A. 39:4-50,
vary depending on whether you have previously been convicted of DWI and
the proven BAC reading as follows:
A. FIRST OFFENSE
– BAC OF .08% AND
UNDER .10% OR “UNDER THE
INFLUENCE.”
FINE: $250.00 to $400.00.
INCARCERATION: "not less than 12 hours nor more than 48
hours spent during two consecutive days of not less than six hours each
day and served . . . [at] the Intoxicated Driver Resource Center . . .
and, in the discretion of the Court, a term of imprisonment of not more
than 30 days."
LOSS OF LICENSE: Three Months.
NEW JERSEY DMV SURCHARGE: $1,000 per year for three years.
OTHER FINES & COSTS: $200.00 DWI Enforcement Fund, $50.00
Violent Crime Compensation Board Fund, $75.00 Safe Neighborhood Fund,
200.00 NJ MVC Restoration Charge(s), $150.00 Intoxicated Driver Resource
Center (IDRC) Fee(s) (Additional fees for out-patient counseling as
referred by the IDRC), and up to $33.00 in Court Costs.
B. FIRST OFFENSE
– BAC OF .10% OR
MORE OR UNDER THE INFLUENCE
OF DRUGS.
FINE: $300.00 to $500.00.
INCARCERATION: "not less than 12 hours nor more than 48
hours spent during two consecutive days of not less than six hours each
day and served . . . [at] the Intoxicated Driver Resource Center . . .
and, in the discretion of the Court, a term of imprisonment of not more
than 30 days."
LOSS OF LICENSE: Seven Months to One Year.
IGNITION INTERLOCK DEVICE: If the BAC was .15% or higher,
the ignition interlock is mandatory for the period of suspension and for
six months to one year thereafter. This is a device installed on a car
that prevents operation if, when blown into, registers a predetermined
blood alcohol concentration.
OTHER FINES & COSTS: $200.00 DWI Enforcement Fund, $50.00
Violent Crime Compensation Board Fund, $75.00 Safe Neighborhood Fund,
200.00 NJ MVC Restoration Charge(s), $150.00 Intoxicated Driver Resource
Center (IDRC) Fee(s) (Additional fees for out-patient counseling as
referred by the IDRC), and up to $33.00 in Court Costs.
B. SECOND OFFENSE:
FINE: $500.00 to $1,000.
COMMUNITY SERVICE: 30 Days.
INCARCERATION: "imprisonment for a term of not less than 48
consecutive hours, which shall not be suspended or served on probation,
nor more than 90 days . . ."
LOSS OF LICENSE: Two Years.
NEW JERSEY DMV SURCHARGE: $1,000 per year for three years.
IGNITION INTERLOCK DEVICE: For the term of the suspension,
and one
to three years following restoration. This is a device installed on a
car that prevents operation if, when blown into, registers a
predetermined blood alcohol concentration.
OTHER FINES & COSTS: $200.00 DWI Enforcement Fund, $50.00
Violent Crime Compensation Board Fund, $75.00 Safe Neighborhood Fund,
200.00 NJ MVC Restoration Charge(s), $150.00 Intoxicated Driver Resource
Center (IDRC) Fee(s) (Additional fees for out-patient counseling as
referred by the IDRC), and up to $33.00 in Court Costs.
C. THIRD OFFENSE:
FINE: $1,000.
INCARCERATION: "imprisonment for a term of not less than
180 days . . ."
LOSS OF LICENSE: Ten Years.
NEW JERSEY DMV SURCHARGE: $1,000.00 per year for three
years unless the conviction happened within three years of the last one
in which case the surcharge is $1,500.00 per year for three years.
IGNITION INTERLOCK DEVICE: For the term of the suspension,
and one
to three years following restoration. This is a device installed on a
car that prevents operation if, when blown into, registers a
predetermined blood alcohol concentration.
OTHER FINES & COSTS: $200.00 DWI Enforcement Fund, $50.00
Violent Crime Compensation Board Fund, $75.00 Safe Neighborhood Fund,
200.00 NJ MVC Restoration Charge(s), $150.00 Intoxicated Driver Resource
Center (IDRC) Fee(s) (Additional fees for out-patient counseling as
referred by the IDRC), and up to $33.00 in Court Costs.
3. Can I obtain a
conditional driver's license to go to and from work if I am convicted?
No. This is probably the most common question I am asked.
The revocation of your driver's license in New Jersey is mandatory for
the prescribed period(s). There are currently no exceptions in New
Jersey Law -
there is
unfortunately
no conditional driver's license for work or otherwise.
4. What will happen
to my insurance coverage and rates if I am convicted?
A New Jersey DWI conviction (or an out-of-state conviction
for a substantially similar Drunk-Driving
offense) permits insurance
carriers to refuse to renew or issue automobile insurance coverage.
Insurance is still available, but through the
"assigned risk" (i.e. high-risk) plan known as NJ P.A.I.P. (New Jersey Personal
Automobile Insurance Plan). Rates will increase dramatically (about
double to triple) for three years.
5. Are there any
defenses to a New Jersey DWI charge?
Yes. A DWI charge is not tantamount to a conviction even in
cases where the police claim a high BAC reading. At the outset, it is
important to remember the old adage: "innocent until proven guilty." The
State (i.e., the Prosecutor through their witnesses) has a
constitutional burden to prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.
Since New Jersey Law provides that a .08% blood alcohol
reading alone is sufficient to sustain a conviction, any defense where
such a reading is alleged usually will focus on the reliability and
validity of the reading (i.e., was the breath machine operated properly,
and was the machine operating properly). If the machine was either not
operating properly, or was not operated properly by a qualified
technician, the test results can be excluded from evidence.
Assuming that the Alcotest (or blood) results can be excluded or
compromised, the State may still seek to prosecute on what is commonly
referred to as "observation" evidence (that the Defendant was "under the
influence"). The "observation" evidence consists of the driving, the
defendant's appearance and demeanor, and field sobriety tests. The
Police Officer(s) will generally testify regarding observations of the
Defendant before and after the arrest (these can include: erratic
driving, flushed face, bloodshot eyes, speech pattern, boisterous
demeanor, odor of alcoholic beverage on breath, hand movements, unsteady
balance, etc.). The Officer(s) will also testify regarding the
Defendant's performance on Field Sobriety Tests (E.G., heel to toe,
finger to nose, one-leg stand, recitation of the alphabet, counting
backwards, etc.).
There might be factors that could have caused the observations and poor
performance on the psychophysical tests, each having nothing to do with
the consumption of alcohol. The observations and field tests should be
scrutinized and screened to prepare for creative and effective
cross-examination at trial. For example, a flushed face (i.e. red face)
is often the result of nervousness, bloodshot eyes may be the result of
allergies, fatigue or irritants, poor balance may be the result of a
medical condition, or as is often the case, the improper administration
of the tests. Some field sobriety tests are simply not scientifically
validated to assess for impairment and may induce failure in sober
people. Experts should, if warranted, be consulted and retained to
address the State's observation case.
The
National Highway Traffic and Safety Administration of the United States
Department of Transportation (NHTSA) recognize only three Field Sobriety
Tests as reliable scientific indicia of intoxication. The Standardized
Field Sobriety Test (SFST) Battery consists of (1) The Horizontal Gaze
Nystagmus (HGN), (2) The Walk and Turn, and (3) The One Leg Stand. These
three tests are regarded as reliable in evaluating alcohol impairment,
provided however, they are properly administered and interpreted. If the
tests are not administered in the prescribed standardized manner, the
test results are rendered compromised.
Like the breath testing, the observation evidence must be
carefully and thoroughly analyzed and assessed to screen for
deficiencies and prepare the case for trial. I have been through the
same detailed training that New Jersey Police receive in DWI Detection
and Standardized Field Sobriety Testing. I have personally administered
field tests to sober and intoxicated people and am familiar with the
detailed training manual(s) published by the Federal Government and used
for training. On this defense front, being intimately familiar with
these tests is the only way to effectively cross-examine the police
officers who administered the tests.
Because my practice
is concentrated on DWI Defense in New Jersey (I do not handle wills,
personal injury cases, matrimonial cases, real estate closings,
bankruptcies, etc.), I probably take more DWI cases to trial in one year
than most lawyers in New Jersey try in their careers. I have tried dwi
cases (from start to finish) in virtually every county in the State. I
have received training in DWI Detection and Standardized Field Sobriety
testing, in the old (phased-out) breathalyzer and recently I received
factory training from the manufacturer of the Alcotest 7110 (Draeger).
You cannot assume that a police-claim regarding a reading is legally
accurate. Through careful analysis, the use of expert-testimony, and
effective cross-examination, a successful challenge to a BAC reading is
possible.
As much as a lawyer
has been taught in law school and from books, you cannot teach
experience or expertise. I learned to drive a car in High School sitting
at a simulator, and then behind the wheel with a driving instructor and
with my father. There are simple skills (like turning the wheel,
stopping, and using the pedals and blinkers) that can be mastered during
training. However, the true "learning to drive" comes from years of
being on the road with other drivers, in varied weather and traffic
conditions, and even navigating around (and surviving) danger.
Similarly, trying numerous DWI cases gives a range of experience and
expertise that cannot be duplicated.
There are other areas to be explored in properly and
thoroughly defending a DWI charge that are beyond the scope of this web
page (e.g., Did the police have legal cause to pull the vehicle over and
to make the arrest?, Are any statements subject to suppression because
Miranda warnings were not issued?, just to name a few).
6. Is there a
difference between DWI and DUI in New Jersey?
No. DWI is an acronym for Driving While Intoxicated. DUI is
an acronym for Driving Under The Influence. Both terms are used to refer
to the charge in New Jersey
– however; the law
makes absolutely no distinction
between a DWI and a DUI.
7. What if I have
been charged with Driving While Intoxicated not by alcohol, but by
drugs?
N.J.S.A. 39:4-50 (the same law that relates to
alcohol-related driving offenses) makes it unlawful to "operate a motor
vehicle while under the influence of
… narcotic,
hallucinogenic or habit
producing drug." The penalties, if convicted, are the same as if you
were convicted of an alcohol-related DWI with a BAC over .10% (First
Offense = 7 month revocation, Etc., Etc.).
In order to convict, the State must prove (1) the presence
of drugs (which will be usually be in the form of blood or urine
evidence), and (2) observations of drug intoxication by a qualified
police officer who has specialized Drug Recognition Expert (DRE)
training. A common mistake made by defense counsel is to equate a
positive specimen result with guilt. Many drugs can be present in the
blood and urine long after their affects are gone (some for days and
weeks after). Further, without qualified testimony from a DRE trained
officer, the State's case will often fail because of this legal
deficiency.
A thorough and effective defense of the so-called
“drugged-driving”
charge will usually entail the use of outside Drug
Recognition Experts and/or Scientists. I work routinely with whom I
regard as the best experts in the field in reviewing the State’s
evidence in
drugged-driving cases. I have been to DWI seminars taught by Drug
Recognition Experts and have the DRE Training Materials. Guilt can never
be assumed in these cases even if the evidence appears strong and there
is positive specimen evidence. Through careful review and the use of the
proper outside experts, the drugged-driving case can be successfully
defended.
8. What are my
chances of winning a DWI case?
There is simply no way of placing numerical odds of success
on any case; including a DWI charge. Further, it is clear that New
Jersey's firm public policy stance against DWI makes the defense of this
charge a challenge even for an experienced, competent and aggressive
defense attorney. The only guarantee any qualified, ethical and
competent attorney can offer is to aggressively analyze and prepare your
case, and guide you through the process.
I
believe that dwi defense can be similar to the practice of medicine. I
was at a party and met a doctor. I asked him what specific field he was
in, and he told me "hand surgery" - I said that is all? He said yes, all
I do is surgery related to the hand. A recent report from the British
Journal of Cancer revealed, "[b]reast
cancer patients operated on 10 years ago by specialists have done better
than those treated by surgeons with fewer breast cancer patients." If
the practice of law is like medicine, you will increase your chances of
success by hiring a lawyer who concentrates in dwi defense.
9. Can I "plea
bargain" a New Jersey DWI charge?
The New Jersey Supreme Court has instructed Municipal
Courts that No plea agreements whatsoever are allowed in New Jersey DWI
cases. A DWI charge is not like a minor moving violation that is often
“plea-bargained” down to a
lesser charge by most prosecutors. I believe that targeting dwi offenses
this way is plainly unjust and troublesome.
A defendant charged with a drive-by-shooting, a rape, even a murder for
hire can engage in plea-bargaining (i.e. plead guilty to a reduced
charge); a defendant charged with dwi in nj cannot. I simply do not
understand that logic.
In some cases, a Prosecutor may however, dismiss a DWI
charge where the State is convinced they will not be able to prove the
charge beyond a reasonable doubt. When a Prosecutor believes that he
cannot convict, he is duty-bound ethically to dismiss the charge or
reduce it to one that conforms to the evidence. I have defended many
cases where the Prosecutor has conceded that the he could not prove the
DWI beyond a reasonable doubt. In those cases, the DWI has either been
dismissed or amended to a charge that conforms to the proofs (such as
careless driving or reckless driving). This is however, distinguishable
from a "plea-bargain."
10. Will my case be
decided by a jury?
No. There is no right to a Jury Trial for DWI offenses.
Trials are presided over by Municipal Court Judges who hear the evidence
and decide both the factual disputes and legal issues.
11. What if I refused
to give samples of my breath?
Refusing to provide samples of your breath is a separate
offense (N.J.S.A.39:4-50.4a) that subjects you to penalties as follows:
1ST OFFENSE: 7-month to 1-year loss of license, $300.00 -
$500.00 fine, $1,000.00 yearly surcharge for three years, referral to
the Intoxicated Driver's Resource Center, and Ignition Interlock for six
months to one year.
2ND OFFENSE: 2 years loss of license, $500.00 to $1,000.00
fine, $1,000.00 yearly surcharge for three years, referral to the
Intoxicated Driver's Resource Center, and Ignition Interlock for the
term of the suspension, and one to three years following restoration.
3RD OFFENSE: 10 years loss of license, $1,000.00 fine,
$1,000.00 yearly surcharge for three years (unless there is a prior
conviction within three years in which case, the surcharge is $1,500.00
per year) and referral to the Intoxicated Driver's Resource Center, and
Ignition Interlock for the term of the suspension, and one
to three years following restoration.
OTHER FINES & COSTS: $200.00 DWI Enforcement Fund, $50.00
Violent Crime Compensation Board Fund, $75.00 Safe Neighborhood Fund,
200.00 NJ MVC Restoration Charge(s), $150.00 Intoxicated Driver Resource
Center (IDRC) Fee(s) (Additional fees for out-patient counseling as
referred by the IDRC), and up to $33.00 in Court Costs. Insurance can
be canceled forcing coverage through he assigned-risk plan
– increasing rates
for about three years.
The penalties are in addition to and consecutive to any
penalties imposed for the underlying drunk driving offense (although on
a offense of dwi and refusal, the court can run the license revocations
concurrently (i.e. together)). A prior DWI conviction in New Jersey or
in another State counts as a prior offense under the Refusal Statute.
This means that if you have a prior DWI or Refusal conviction, it will
count to enhance your sentencing exposure.
12. What if my
"rights" were not read?
This is a very common question. Police do not have to
advise you of your "Miranda" Rights (including your right to remain
silent) during roadside interrogation (unless the interrogation takes
longer than is necessary and turns into a
"de facto"
arrest). Being taken into custody is generally what triggers Miranda warnings to be given.
If your rights were not read and they should have been,
your case will not magically be dismissed on a so-called "technicality."
The utility of a Miranda warning failure in a defense arsenal is that
any statements you made may be subject to being suppressed (i.e.,
excluded).
13. If I have an
out-of-state DWI conviction, will it count in New Jersey as a prior
offense?
An out of state conviction for a DWI law of a
“substantially
similar”
nature will constitute a prior offense in New Jersey. It is,
however, possible to exclude the out of state conviction by proof that
the conviction was based solely upon a violation of a proscribed BAC of
less than .08%. Sometimes, a prior conviction does not show up in a
defendant's driving history. This presents an extremely delicate
situation. The State has the burden to prove each element of the
offense, and has the burden to establish prior offenses. A lawyer has an
ethical duty of candor to the Court and to the Prosecutor, and if asked
directly by the Judge, a defendant risks a charge of perjury or contempt
if he lies. On the other hand, a defendant has an absolute
constitutional right to remain silent including at sentencing (to "take
the fifth"). In addition, a lawyer owes allegiance to his client not to
reveal privileged information (the lawyer can and ethically assert
"attorney-client privilege" with regard to the knowledge of a prior
offense. This scenario presents a most uncomfortable position for
defense counsel. However, through a careful balancing of the opposing
duties, and careful and ethical advocacy, the prior offense can usually
be neutralized.
14. What if I am
licensed in another State and am found guilty of DWI in New Jersey?
New Jersey Courts only have jurisdiction (i.e. the
authority) over your driving privileges in New Jersey. A New Jersey DWI
conviction will usually be shared with the State where you are licensed.
Thereafter, that State generally can take action against your driving
privileges there
– independent of what happens in New Jersey. This is known as the law of
"reciprocity."
15. What will happen
if I am convicted of DWI or Refusal to Submit, lose my license, and
drive during the period of suspension?
If you are convicted of driving while suspended, the Court
must (1) fine you $500.00, (2) suspend your driving privileges for one
to two years, and (3) order your imprisonment in the county jail for 10
to 90 days. The driving while revoked charge (N.J.S. 39:3-40) when the
reason for the revocation is a dwi or refusal conviction presents a
challenge. There are in my experience, defense issues and angles whereby
the jail term can be mitigated, or the charge itself can be defended or
downgraded.
16. Is a New Jersey
DWI conviction a crime?
No, a DWI in New Jersey
is classified as a motor vehicle (traffic) violation, not a "crime",
"felony", "misdemeanor", or "disorderly person's offense." This is a
very common
question. I
am asked this question at least once a week.
Some law in New
Jersey refers to a NJ DWI as a
“quasi-criminal” offense;
however, that
classification has to be
read in context. The charge is
“quasi-criminal”
to the extent that a
DWI-Defendant is entitled to the same constitutional safeguards that
Defendants facing crimes have. The prevailing law clearly regards the
offense as a traffic violation.
17. Should I hire an
attorney?
DWI in New Jersey is extremely complex and a conviction
carries with it very harsh consequences. There are no guarantees that an
attorney, even if qualified and experienced, will be able to
successfully defend you. However, a qualified and experienced attorney
can carefully review your case for defects, request and compel discovery
of breath machine records and relevant police records and reports from
the Police and Prosecution, consult with and retain expert witnesses,
and prepare your case for trial.
Be apprehensive of counsel that a DWI case cannot be won.
That pessimistic attitude is generally borne from the lack of knowledge
of the intricacies of DWI law, and the lack of experience trying (and
winning) DWI cases. You should, likewise, be suspicious of counsel that
paints too "rosy a picture" since that attorney may be primarily
motivated by his interests and not yours.
If you choose an
attorney, you should choose one who is qualified and experienced
(including DWI trials) in this very complex area of law, who keeps
abreast of the laws relating to DWI, and one who is going to thoroughly
and diligently review and prepare your case to the end that you obtain
the best and most aggressive possible defense.
You should also look
for a lawyer who is passionate and committed to his profession, not one
who views your case as part of being on the proverbial
“grind-stone.”
There is no substitute for passion and commitment in any profession or trade
– these motivating
qualities lead to a quest for excellence.
Most
importantly, you should look for a lawyer whose practice is focused on
DWI Law. If you needed heart surgery, you would seek out a heart
surgeon, not a generalist. Likewise, you will be best served by hiring a
focused DWI Defense Lawyer for your defense, not a generalist.
See Tips On Hiring A Lawyer For Your New
Jersey DWI Case. And
THE SMART CONSUMER GUIDE TO NJ DWI LAWYERS FOUR THINGS THAT YOUR LAWYER
MIGHT NOT WANT YOU TO KNOW.
If you have any questions,
you are welcome to call me:
Office: 1-973-994-3732
Cell: 1-201-404-8990
Call
on New Jersey
DWI lawyer, Greggory M. Marootian when you need
experienced
professionals to give you the facts, and restore your integrity.
|